
Serves: you decide
Potato salad is another one of those summer favorites that I regularly get asked for a recipe for, and it's also one of those things that you just have to play fast and loose with. There's no such thing as a recipe for potato salad, at least not in my kitchen, but there are a few rules. The most important thing is to leave plenty of time for it to chill in the fridge. I like to do mine up the night before to allow the flavors to meld together.
Must have:
potatoes (any kind - and I leave the skins on)
eggs
purple onion
pickles (I prefer dill, but sweet will do)
Best Foods mayonaise
plain yellow mustard (like French's)
salt
pepper
lemon pepper
paprika
Nice to have:
red and/or yellow bell pepper
mild to medium hot pepper (I like red jalapenos)
celery
green onion
balsamic vinegar
dill
fresh basil
lemon zest
Rough measurements:
I generally figure about 1 potato per person if it's a major part of the meal, a bit less if I'm taking it to a pot luck, and then use half as many eggs as potatoes. The rest of the ingredients are pretty much based on what you feel is balanced.
Start by cutting up your potatoes into 1" cubes and then put them in a pot cold water and put them on to boil. Put a lid on them just until they start to boil, then remove the lid and let them boil until they're just soft enough to put a fork through easily. You don't want them to be too soft or they will fall apart when you start to mix them.
Since you're waiting for your potatoes, boil your eggs. Recently I found an article online at
What's Cooking America which taught me more than I ever thought I'd want to know about boiling an egg. I followed the instructions diligently and I must say I turned out the best boiled eggs I've ever produced.
I like to cut stuff up while I'm waiting for the main parts to cook. Dice your onions and pickles, and peppers and celery if you're using them. Zest the lemon and chiffonade the basil and pull together anything else you're going to put in there.
When the potatoes are done, drain them and put them into a large bowl. Peel and dice your eggs and add them to the potatoes. Add the other stuff you've chopped up and give it a stir. Now you can start adding in the mayonnaise. Start with one cup and fold it into the solid ingredients. You want it to bind everything together without it being runny. If you need more add it in sparingly because it's difficult to come back from runny. When it holds together you can add in some mustard.
Now begins the process of tasting and seasoning and tasting and stirring and wondering if it will all come together in the refrigerator and seasoning and tasting. Err on the side of caution and remember that it will get stronger as it sits.
Recipe by: Kelly Sink